There’s no single criterion, but there are some reliable indicators of performance and stability. Reputable suppliers list as many technical properties as possible, especially for general-purpose greases.
A general-purpose grease should have a base oil viscosity of between 100 and 200 mm²/s at 40 °C; up to 10% above that is fine. Besides base oil viscosity and corrosion protection, look at the results of the four-ball test (VKA) or the SRV test (oscillating friction and wear test). In the four-ball test, a weld load of around 320 kg or higher is a solid result.
Note: expressed in newtons, that’s around 3,140 N, which simply looks more impressive. A wear scar of 0.5 mm or less is also a good sign. If oil separation is specified as well, which is rare, you can assume you’re looking at a very good grease.
Naturally, good to excellent performance and stability come at a higher price.
If a grease has hardened, become gummy or turned brown, it has usually got too hot and some of the oil has evaporated.
Possible solutions:
Mixing two general-purpose greases usually isn’t a problem.
It’s very difficult to remove all of the wrong grease without taking the bearing out. In our experience, purging the bearing with around three times its free volume flushes out most of it. The remaining 15–20% only reduces gradually over many relubrication cycles.
Upper temperature limits leave plenty of room for interpretation. They often refer only to short-term peaks, with no defined duration. A general-purpose grease can be used safely up to 80 °C, although you should review your relubrication intervals.
In theory, you could use a general-purpose grease at 180 °C. But it ages so quickly at that temperature that you’d practically have to relubricate every minute to keep it working.
Check the data sheets for the base oil and thickener type, then compare them against a compatibility chart for base oils and thickeners.
If you don’t know exactly what’s in a grease, a simple hands-on test can help: mix equal amounts of both greases and leave them to stand for 24–48 hours. If they show any tendency to separate, they’re definitely incompatible. PFPE-based greases can generally only be mixed with other PFPE-based greases.
Look at two things: the base oil and the temperature it’s rated for in continuous operation. A PAO-based grease claiming 220 °C isn’t realistic. That figure usually only applies for a very short, unspecified period. PFPE-based greases, on the other hand, can safely be used at their stated temperatures, although there are different types to consider here as well.
That depends mainly on the temperature, as well as the grease’s thickener and base oil. Heat makes grease age very quickly. As a rule of thumb, grease life halves with every 10 °C rise above 60 °C.
At least 20 °C above your actual operating temperature. The bigger the margin, the longer your relubrication intervals.
It comes down to the raw materials. Depending on the type, PFPE-based greases can cost up to 50 times as much as a basic high-temperature grease. In return, they can last up to 1,000 times longer, which allows very long relubrication intervals.
There can be several reasons: the temperature is too high and the relubrication intervals too long, the grease simply can’t cope with the thermal load, the mechanical load is too high, or the grease has already aged thermally on its way to the lubrication point.
As long as there’s no radiation exposure, there are more affordable high-temperature greases, and some may even outperform the one you’re using.
It’s very difficult to remove all of the wrong grease without taking the bearing out. In our experience, purging the bearing with around three times its free volume flushes out most of it. The remaining 15–20% only reduces gradually over many relubrication cycles.
The grease is under severe thermal stress and needs relubricating.
Possible causes include the bearing geometry, how grease escapes from the bearing, the bearing seals, the relubrication quantity and frequency, and finally the types of grease used.
If you don’t know exactly what’s in them, mix equal amounts of both greases and leave them to stand for 24–48 hours. If they show any tendency to separate, they’re incompatible. PFPE-based greases can generally only be mixed with other PFPE-based greases.
The grease is thermally overloaded and the relubrication interval is too long.
If you use a different grease for each bearing, mix-ups are inevitable. Instead, use the high-temperature grease suited to the most heavily loaded bearing for all the others as well, and base the relubrication interval on the shortest one.
Apart from a rated temperature below −20 °C, look at the base oil viscosity, the base oil type and the viscosity index. Low-temperature greases have a low base oil viscosity of around 5–46 mm²/s. Viscosity changes with temperature: the colder it gets, the thicker the oil becomes.
Yes, in most cases. Both types share the same key properties, including a relatively low base oil viscosity of under 46 mm²/s.
As a guide, relubricate once a month with 25% of the bearing’s free volume, or less often depending on the load.
At least 10 °C above your actual operating temperature.
Synthetic greases outperform mineral oil-based ones. The grease should be rated for temperatures below −20 °C.
Yes, it can be. In that case, it’s most likely a grease based on linear PFPE. These have an extremely high viscosity index and therefore excellent viscosity-temperature behaviour.
Below the lowest recommended temperature, the base oil solidifies and can no longer flow, and lubrication breaks down. As these figures are often based on the pour point (DIN 51597 / EN 3015:2019), the actual limit in dynamic operation can be significantly lower.
If you don’t know exactly what’s in them, mix equal amounts of both greases and leave them to stand for 24–48 hours. If they show any tendency to separate, they’re incompatible. PFPE-based greases can generally only be mixed with other PFPE-based greases.
It’s very difficult to remove all of the wrong grease without taking the bearing out. In our experience, purging the bearing with around three times its free volume flushes out most of it. The remaining 15–20% only reduces gradually over many relubrication cycles.
Observation: The 20-metre chain has elongated by 3% within three months. The oven only runs at 200 °C, and the chain looks permanently wet with oil.
Assessment: Provided the oil is ester-based with a viscosity of around 300 mm²/s at 40 °C, the chain oil can largely be ruled out as the sole cause.
Possible causes:
Note: In the last two cases, corrosion and overload, the right chain oil can actually help solve the problem.
Observation: Although the chain is lubricated regularly and apparently sufficiently, it runs stiffly and its power draw has risen significantly.
Possible causes:
Solutions:
Bottom line: A stiff chain with high power draw is often caused by deposits or wear rather than poor lubrication. The right lubricant and cleaning method can help restore normal operation.
Observation: Chain oil consumption has risen significantly. Despite regular lubrication, far too much oil seems to be running through the system.
Possible causes:
Bottom line: High oil consumption is often caused not by the oil itself, but by poor application, a lubrication setup that hasn’t kept pace with the process, or contamination nobody has noticed. A targeted review of the lubrication points, temperature profile and nozzle position is key to improving efficiency and cutting consumption.
Possible causes and solutions:
Bottom line: Smoke is usually caused by large temperature differences, overdosing or the wrong oil. Technical adjustments and the right product can keep it to a minimum.
Possible causes:
Bottom line: Sprocket wear is often caused by play in the mechanics, poor chain guidance or overloaded components. Regular checks of all related parts are essential to prevent further damage.
In general, any fine-grained or powdered substance, such as sand or talc, counts as a dry or solid lubricant.
In industry, they’re only used in exceptional cases. They’re usually applied with a carrier that evaporates over time, and the real challenge is keeping the lubricant where it’s needed. Above 400 °C, however, there’s no alternative.
The most common solid lubricants in industrial use are graphite, MoS₂, boron nitride and PTFE.
Graphite, MoS₂, boron nitride or PTFE? Each has its strengths, and the best choice depends on the application. Here’s how they perform in their dry state:
Summary: Decades of experience show that graphite, the messiest of these solids, also has the most versatile, high-level properties in practice, and it’s very inexpensive. MoS₂ is well established and works well in oils and pastes. Boron nitride is popular for its good wear protection and white colour. PTFE is valued for being inert, stable under high pressure and clean.